RE: [load balancing] F5 BigIP HA Questions

From: Barrett, John (John.BarrettIZZATFMR.COM)
Date: Tue Jan 06 2004 - 08:24:52 EST

  • Next message: Chris Kirby: "RE: [load balancing] F5 BigIP HA Questions"

    Actually using the F5 device to terminate SSL connections is possible
    without a SSL card. However, it does depend on the license and version of
    code. We do it here on test devices using the proxy features. It works
    great, but it's slow as death with any type of load.


    -----Original Message-----
    From: Winter, R. Stephen []
    Sent: Monday, January 05, 2004 9:31 PM
    Subject: RE: [load balancing] F5 BigIP HA Questions

    Mike, A quick caution before you but a second-hand pair. There is a
    license file on the BigIP's that is required for the software to work. If
    that's not there, you will need to "register" with F5 (we paid about 5k for
    an HA pair I think, but we wanted maintenance and everything) If you lose
    the hard-drive, you will need that license file, so make sure you copy it
    somewhere safe. Also, if you ever change the NIC, you'll have problems.
    The license is tied to the MAC address...

    Ok.. Without the SSL card you will not be able to terminate the SSL on the
    Big IP. But, you can still load balance by passing the packets directly to
    an SSL Server. I don't remember if the F5 can read the SSL ID, but I know
    we did have some issues with the renegotiating of the SSL ID's, so you will
    need to setup a different type of persistence (mabye by source address will
    work for your situation)

    The source address of the original packet can be retained (default unless
    you add the Natting). In a "normal" config, you usually only re-write the
    destination address to the pool member. You can NAT the source address if
    you want to. (and sometimes you need to). If you don't NAT, you will need
    the BigIP to be the default gateway. You can setup the BigIP to NAT on the
    way or (or not) for the pool member initiating traffic out pas the BigIP if
    you do have it as the default gateway... (If you don't NAT, you can set it
    to forward as well...)

    I hope I wrote this as clearly as I saw it in my head...

    -----Original Message-----
    From: Michael Ferraro []
    Sent: Monday, January 05, 2004 3:55 PM
    Subject: [load balancing] F5 BigIP HA Questions


    We're about to buy a pair of F5 BigIPs in the secondary market and I had
    a few questions I was hoping somebody could help us with. Since we're
    not looking to buy new, we can't really have the F5 sales engineers
    helping us out too much...

    If the BigIP doesn't have an SSL accelerator, what functionality do we
    lose aside from rapid decryption/re-encryption of traffic? Can a BigIP
    still function as an SSL endpoint without the card? My impression is

    If the BigIP can't be an SSL endpoint w/out an SSL Accelerator card, how
    would it function to load-balance HTTPS traffic? My assumption is that
    it can read the SSL session ID w/out decrypting the packets, use round
    robin (or another method) to distribute the connections among pool
    members, and use that SSL session ID to route future requests for that
    session to the same pool member. If that's true, what about IE 5.5+'s
    habit of changing (renegotiating) SSL IDs periodicially? Can BigIP
    v4.2.6 account for that?

    When NAT'ing traffic to pool members, is the source IP address unchanged
    by the BigIP? If not, I'm assuming that I have to have the BigIP's IP
    be the default router for my pool members. Yuck. If the BigIP is the
    default router, what about non-HTTPS traffic (e.g., SSH) originating
    from the pool members -- will it simply forward that traffic, too?

    Thanks in advance!


    The Load Balancing Mailing List
    MRTG with SLB:
    Hosted by:

    NOTICE: This communication and any attachments may contain privileged or
    otherwise confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient
    or believe that you may have received this communication in error, please
    reply to the sender indicating that fact and delete the copy you received
    without printing, copying, retransmitting, disseminating, or otherwise using
    the information. Thank you.

    The Load Balancing Mailing List
    MRTG with SLB:
    Hosted by:
    The Load Balancing Mailing List
    MRTG with SLB:
    Hosted by:

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.4 : Tue Jan 06 2004 - 08:43:08 EST